|Paper. . . Your Most Valuable Tool
ASIDE FROM YOUR charm and good looks, you may find "paper" to be your most powerful tool
as an agent, investor or exchangor. Creative real estate might be boring without it. As an agent and broker
for 20 years, I've found my knowledge and use of paper to be my most valuable tool.
I began as a real estate investor and agent. I did the tenants and toilets game for what seems like a
hundred years. I sort of backed my way into paper investment. I learned to use notes in my investing,
and mortgage buyers became a valuable resource. I work with Realtors daily as a mortgage buyer and teach
continuing education for the State of Utah. Throughout The Paper Game and my other books, I have
techniques that I teach Realtors. Instead of having everyone read a thousand pages of materials or go
through 5 days of video tapes, I decided to compile the techniques into "The Alternative Financing
Toolkit." Here are the first five techniques in the volume. I hope they work for you as well as they
have for me.
CREATE A SECOND AND THIRD -- SELL THE SECOND
Sometimes you will run into a situation where a buyer is willing to pay a good price for a property but
does not have the needed cash to assume the existing financing or the ability to refinance with a large
down payment. Many times the seller wants or needs a particular amount of cash and might consider a
discount off of the price in exchange for the needed cash. Using private financing and your knowledge of
seller financing, here is a technique that works very well.
Lets's say that the buyer is short of as much cash as the seller requires, but the seller is willing to
discount his property a little in exchange for the cash (or the buyer is willing to pay a little over
market). When the seller has a large portion of his equity that will be taken back in paper and is willing
to discount a little, there is a way to put this deal together.
The seller wants $17,000 cash, but the buyer only has $10,000 to work with. To get the
extra cash the seller would be willing to discount a few thousand off the market price. The buyer is
willing to pay full price, but needs a lower down. The value of the property is $50,000. Here are
The way to put this deal together is to take the seller's discount and use it to generate the cash.
Instead of creating one $25,000 second to the seller, create a $10,000 second and a
$15,000 third. The $10,000 second is sold in the marketplace for $7,000 cash and the
third is given to the seller. The seller now has his terms and his cash and the buyer has his terms.
The Buyer pays $50,000 with $10,000 down, assumes the $15,000 second and pays the
seller on a $10,000 private second and a $15,000 private third. The seller gets $10,000
cash down, assumption of the $15,000 first, $7,000 from the sale of the second to a
"paper investor" and receives payments on a $25,000 seller carry back. His total is
$47,000 and both buyer and seller have had their needs met.
PRIORITIZED COMMISSION NOTES
Many deals fail to close when there is just a small distance between the needs of the seller and the buyer.
Much of the time, the amount of cash being received by the seller is the issue and the agent could close
a deal if they took their commission on a note.
Agents and their brokers tend to shy away from this option because they feel they need immediate cash
and see no alternative with a note other than collecting payments. If structured properly, the commission
note could be set up to be salable immediately with very little discount and the deal could be saved. You
can as much as double your sales if you don't walk away so easily from the ones that come close.
Those agents that do take their commissions in the form of a note usually create a note that is not
salable. Even that would be better than a deal that doesn't close, but there is a better way.
A note that is secured by real estate with a safe loan to value ratio (usually 80% or less) is
readily salable. Let's look at two scenarios. The first is the standard way most agents would approach
the transaction. The second one includes a simple change that makes a major difference.
$100,000 Sale price
$ 60,000 Existing first loan (assumable)
$ 10,000 Down payment from buyer
$ 23,000 Second to seller (private seller financing)
$ 7,000 Third trust deed to broker for commission
Many brokers wouldn't even insist on a trust deed note to secure their commission, yet this third may not
be very salable. The loan to value ratio is 90% and most note buyers would not buy a third with
only 10% equity above them. Now for one simple change.
$100,000 Sale price
$ 60,000 Existing first loan (assumable)
$ 10,000 Down payment from buyer
$ 7,000 Second trust deed to broker for commission
$ 23,000 Third to seller (private seller financing)
The broker takes his commission in a second position and the seller subordinates his note to a
third position. When the seller requests you take your commission on a note, it is not out of place to
insist that your note is safe and salable. Usually this will be a small note and will be paid off soon.
When the second is paid off, the seller's note, which is currently in a third position, will drop down
into the second position. You can also structure this transaction so that all of the payments on the
seller financing go to your second trust deed note until it is paid. More on that later.
LOWER THE RATE, RAISE THE BALANCE
This is a valuable technique to help bring buyers and sellers together that are in disagreement about
the price to be paid for the property. A tremendous negotiation technique
Let's say that a buyer has offered $85,000 for a property and will assume a $40,000 first
loan. The down payment will be $15,000 and the seller would receive a $30,000 second loan
at 13% payable $331.86 per month. The seller wants $11,000 more for the property.
The buyer thinks a price of $96,000 is ridiculous, but wants the property. What do you do? Would
you walk away? Beat on the buyer and seller trying to get them to agree on price?
|1st Loan (Assume):
|2nd to Seller:
In many cases where the seller is hung up on price, he may not be as hung up on terms. Do you know
you can please both the buyer and seller at the same time? If the buyer offered a $41,244.16
note at 9% the payments would be $331.86 per month for the same period of time as the
first note. Does the buyer pay any more? No! Does the seller receive his price? Yes! (Even a little more.)
Both notes, if discounted, are worth exactly the same amount. The real difference is how it looks. You
just have the negotiating advantage of understanding the correlation between interest rate and price.
A small change in the interest rate can make a large difference. The buyer will pay the same amount and
the seller will receive the same amount. The difference is in the packaging. Here are the original terms
of the $30,000 note and the terms of the new note.
The strategy is to look at an interest rate adjustment when the seller and buyer are
apart on price. A few percent difference in the interest rate can mean a difference of thousands of
dollars in the long run.
GRADUATED PAYMENT BALLOON ALTERNATIVE
Balloon payments are like time bombs sometimes. A foreclosure in embryo. A potential problem and lawsuit.
There are better alternatives than balloon payments that will accomplish the same goals without the risks.
A common situation that is created is where the buyer has a 30 year amortization on his or her note and
a 5 year balloon payment. A $30,000 note might look like the following.
The amount of the balloon payment in 5 years would be almost $29,000. Where is the buyer
going to get the cash? Can he refinance? What are the rates? Is financing available? Is the buyer still
financable? These are some important risks.
If the buyer began with the same payment of $263.27 per month, but raised it by $50 each
year, the loan would pay off in less than one third the time of the original. Instead of a nasty,
potentially hazardous balloon payment in 60 months, the loan would fully amortize in 106
months. The sellers achieve their goal of getting their money out quickly, with less risk of problems
and taking the property back. The buyer has a far more palatable scenario of a gradual increase in his
payments. If the payments become a burden, the buyer can refinance at a time that makes sense (60
months may not).
BALLOON PAYMENT ROLLOVER PROVISION
Another alternative to a balloon payment is to have an extension provision that will give the buyer some
time to raise funds or workable financing. This may be a provision that allows for a one year extension
of the balloon payment upon the payment of 10% of the outstanding principle balance. In the
previous example, the balloon payment of $28,972 could be extended for a year upon payment of
$2,897 in principle on the note. This can be structured as a one time or continuous provision.
That means that the next year the same provision could apply if financing were tight. The clause can
also be qualified as to available financing and interest rates. This is just a sample of some of the ways
agents can use paper to improve their profits.
© 2000 Cashflow Specialists. All rights reserved.
John D. Behle, is one of the premier educators and practitioners in the field of "Real Estate Paper".
John has an extensive background in consulting and coaching. In addition to the original "The Paper Game"
book published in 1982, he is the author of 7 other books, several home study courses and over 200
nationally published magazine and newsletter articles on paper investment. You can visit him on the web at
Back to Real Estate Investing Articles